Lap-Band System vs. REALIZE Band

Lap-Band System vs. REALIZE Band2018-10-12T22:32:43+00:00

Lap Band Surgery

Adjustable Gastric Banding (AGB) used to be one of the most common weight loss procedures. This procedure requires the use of an implant. In the United States, only two implants are FDA approved: REALIZE Band and Lap-Band System.

Both procedures are done laparoscopically as well as with single-incision through the belly button with little scaring. This procedure has a proven track record for patients who are able to follow the postoperative nutritional guidelines and learn to do portion control.

Differences Between Lap-Band vs Realize Band?

There are very slight differences between Lap-Band to REALIZE. Both accomplish the same goal and functions in very similar ways. Most surgeons say that the differences are subtle, and the use of one or another is based on the surgeon’s preference.

Lap-Band System vs. REALIZE Band Table Comparison

Implant:
REALIZE Band
Lap-Band System
CompanyEthicon Endo-Surgery, Inc., part of Johnson & JohnsonAllergan, Inc.
Origin/First VersionDeveloped in Sweden in 1985.Developed in Belgium in 1993.
U.S. FDA Approval DateSeptember 2007 (Approved in Europe Before)June 2001
US Clinical TrialsStarted in 2003Started in 1995
Patient Use100,000 Worldwide Patients650,000 Worldwide Patients
Band VersionsTwo U.S. versions

  • 2007 – REALIZE Band
  • 2009 – REALIZE Band-C
Three generations with continual improvements

  • 2001 – The 9.75/10 LAP-BAND System
  • 2004 – The LAP-BAND VG System
  • 2007 – The LAP-BAND AP System
AdjustabilityOne size, fully adjustableTwo sizes, fully adjustable
Average AdjustmentsFive to Eight in 2 years4 First Year, 2 Second and Third Year
RecallHad a Recall In 2010.None Known.
ReversibilityYesYes
ResultsAt 3 Years

  • 83% of Patients Lost 43% of Their Excess Weight
At 1 Year

  • 40-50% Excess Weight Lost

LAP-BAND System by Allergan

Lap-Band system is an implant from Allergan Corporation. The Lap-Band is the first AGB device approved by FDA in the United State for weight loss procedure. For patients who are in the United States. The Lap-Band is comparable in expected weight loss to the Realize Band. Allergan claims that their gastric band exerts equal pressure on all sides of the esophagus and stomach and as a result, it reduces the chance of erosion. The Lap-Band is offered in two different sizes. Lap-Band system is one of the most popular procedures and is widely known in the media.

REALIZE Band System by Johnson & Johnson

REALIZE Band, is an implant from the Ethicon Endo-Surgery, part of Johnson & Johnson Company. The Realize Band is the second AGB device approved by FDA in the United State for weight loss procedure in 2007. However, the REALIZE band was approved in Europe long before and has a track record of success. The REALIZE Band has been implanted in over 100,000 patients. The Realize Band offers a comprehensive aftercare program (at REALIZE mySuccess) designed to help patients reach their weight loss goals. J & J claims that their gastric band has a low-pressure system that supports wider fill ranges and as a result, has a lower risk of band erosion. The Realize Band is offered in one size that fits all.

Other Comparisons: