Read This Before You Decide to Try AspireAssist

AspireAssist vs. Gastric Sleeve, Gastric Bypass, and Other Bariatric Surgery – How Does it Compare?

Aspire Assist

Recently, the FDA approved a new bariatric surgery and weight loss device. Known as AspireAssist from Aspire Bariatrics, this stomach-pumping device is one of the few reversible bariatricsurgery procedures to receive FDA approval. Others include the Lap-Band and the Gastric Balloon.

The Aspire Assist is a very different type of technology. It is the first and only device that, rather than reduce hunger or prevent overeating, allows the individual to eat almost as much food as they want with few to no food restrictions. But how does it work and, perhaps more importantly, is it better than other bariatric surgery procedures?

What is the AspireAssist and How Does it Work?

In this story, put together by ABC News and posted on their YouTube Channel, they share just what AspireAssist is and how it works. You can see by the comments and high number of dislikes that it is not a popular choice. Direct Link to Video

 

iStock_000013351159_MediumCompressed (1)The AspireAssist is a device that is connected to your stomach directly and acts like a “Food Hoover.” After eating, the device can be used suck the food out of the stomach like a vacuum, and dump the food into a receptacle (usually a toilet) so that it can be flushed like food waste.

It has been nicknamed “stomach sucker,” because of the way it empties the stomach, almost like regurgitating food. It uses a valve mechanism that sucks the digesting food out of the stomach and directly into the toilet.

What is the Surgery Like?

The procedure may not be considered a surgery at all. It is minimally invasive, and the procedure is almost identical to the way that feeding tubes are inserted into the stomach. In fact, the procedure is so similar that often it is performed by gastroenterologists, not bariatric surgeons.

The entire AspireAssist procedure takes only about 15 minutes, with a fast recovery time. It can also be removed with a 10 to 15-minute procedure. Complications are very rare. General Anesthesia is also not necessary. Most patients use only Twilight Anesthesia – the patient is awake but too sedated to worry about the procedure.

Does AspireAssist Work?

According to a study in Sweden, the AspireAssist does help patients lose weight when also combined with Cognitive Behavioral Therapy. Keep in mind there was no control group (it is generally recommended that all research use a control group for reference), but average weight loss was 40% excess body weight over a period of 6 months.

AspireAssist Complications, Dangers, and Warnings

The procedure itself generally has few complications. Because it is related to the feeding tube procedure, it is a very well-known and safe procedure with a low mortality rate.

Yet AspireAssist is not without challenges. One such challenge is making food small enough to fit through the system. The tube is very small. Food needs to be chewed to pieces that are 5mm or smaller, which is less than the size of most normal chewed food. If food is not chewed to such a small size, it will not pass through the tube and get stuck. This is not dangerous but it can be inconvenient.

The makers of AspireAssist note that this is partially on purpose, as eating food too quickly is one of the causes of continued obesity.

Also, the long-term effects of pumping food out of your stomach are not yet known. Many refer to this type of device as “assisted bulimia,” because it purges food similar to the way that someone suffering from an eating disorder may purge the food.

Those suffering from bulimia frequently have vitamin and nutritional deficiencies, as most nutrients are processed in the intestines, not the stomach, and the food is removed before it has a chance to be processed.

Finally, the overall safety is still an unknown. As Laura Beck of Jezebel puts it {{warning, the article contains bad language}}:

“I’m sure it won’t be long until tales of infections, leakage, lack of nutrient absorption, depression and suicide, severe hypoglycemia, extreme thiamine deficiency, anemia, osteoporosis, and all sorts of other complications will surface. In many cases, these are the things that are more dangerous than just being fat.”

iStock_000040158946_Medium (1)Additional Challenges to AspireAssist

Though not considered a complication, the willingness to frequently remove food through a tube into a toilet is also questionable. Many patients may find they do not have the time, energy, or motivation to go through the process. Many also consider it “gross,” including the CEO of Aspire Bariatrics.

It is also not clear if this type of procedure will help control obesity in the long term. Some consider it an enabling device that may teach those with obesity bad habits about eating, making them feel as though they can eat what they want and simply remove it afterward. According to one doctor: “This is mechanized bulimia. It’s a device that makes bulimia okay.”

But the early patients that have tried the machine do report success. They claim that the sheer amount of chewing necessary to use the device teaches them to slow down their eating significantly. Said one patient: “You have to chew your food beyond comprehension … I mean, you just don’t grasp how much you have to chew your food.”

“At some point, they just get tired of chewing,”; [one lead researcher] says. " So they are feeling that full sensation with less food because they’re eating slower and they’re also literally just getting sick and tired of chewing.”

How AspireAssist Compares to Other Weight Loss Surgeries

It’s unclear whether being “tired of chewing” is a valid weight loss strategy. But early weight loss results, at 40% excess body weight, may be helpful for some obese patients that are opposed to permanent types of weight loss surgery. But how does it compare?

AspireAssist vs. Gastric Sleeve – Comparison

Gastric Sleeve SurgeryAspireAssist falls short of the weight loss of gastric sleeve surgery. Gastric Sleeve is known to remove 60% of excess body weight on average, compared to the 40% of AspireAssist. Gastric Sleeve is also known to reduce hunger, does not have any complications with food size or infections, and requires very few food restrictions unless you notice an increased sensitivity to certain foods after the procedure is over.

The primary advantage of AspireAssist over Gastric Sleeve is that AspireAssist is reversible. If you decide you no longer want to use AspireAssist, it can be easily removed.

Finally, it may also be cheaper if paying out of pocket in the United States, and the time of the procedure is both shorter – with only a few hours spent at the hospital.

Gastric Bypass SurgeryAspireAssist vs. Gastric Bypass – Comparison

Gastric Bypass has similar advantages and disadvantages to AspireAssist as gastric sleeve. It is also a permanent procedure. Weight loss is comparable, if not slightly better, than gastric sleeve at 65%. It also reduces hunger and is known to be a safe option in the long term.

Gastric bypass does come with more complications compared to Gastric Sleeve, including dumping syndrome. It also comes with more food restrictions, which means that you are more limited in your food choices than you would be with AspireAssist.

Nevertheless, the success rate and safety rate if gastric bypass is second to none, as the procedure has been frequently studied for decades, and had long been considered the premier choice for weight loss surgery before the last few years when gastric sleeve took over.

AspireAssist, which has not been around as long as either procedure, does not have the long safety rating. It also requires the frequent emptying of the stomach and long chewing time, which neither gastric sleeve nor gastric bypass requires.

Lap-band SurgeryAspire Assist vs. Lap-Band (Adjustable Gastric Banding) – Comparison

In terms of total weight loss and safety, AspireAssist does not compare that well to the gastric sleeve and gastric bypass. Its primary benefit is an easier surgery and reversible procedure, but safety is still a question.

However, AspireAssist does compare somewhat favorably to Lap Band – at least when you remove the “Gross” factor. Both procedures:

  • Are Removable
  • Lead to 40% Excess Weight Loss First Year
  • Utilize a Minimally Invasive Surgery

Although new to the bariatric market, research does support a few benefits of AspireAssist over Lap-Band, including:

  • Shorter Procedure Time
  • No Increase in Acid Reflux
  • Less Risk of Surgical Complications

However, Lap Band has some advantages over AspireAssist as well, including:

  • Limited Food Intake (Better for Learning New Behaviors)
  • More Testing – Less Risk of Infection
  • Proven Long-Term Efficacy

It is tempting to believe that AspireAssist is safer and provides more benefits when compared to Lap-Band, and if the claims of AspireAssist end up confirmed in future research, it is possible that it may be a better reversible option.

But one of the best ways to determine whether or not a bariatric technology is effective is to test it for years and years – not only in studies funded by Aspire but also in studies funded by surgical leaders throughout the United States. These have not yet been completed, so Lap-Band has a significant advantage – even with similar weight loss results.

tape-403593_1920 copyOverall Impressions of AspireAssist Weight Loss Surgery

AspireAssist is an interesting new technology. But it struggles with three main issues:

1) It is Gross – While “gross” is subjective, it is difficult to imagine that adults will be comfortable dumping their stomach contents into toilets on a frequent basis. They would need to do it frequently – multiple times a day – and the scent and messiness of it may cause many people to skip dumping, which in turn will not provide additional weight loss.

2) It Is New/Risky – There is nothing inherently wrong with being new. Gastric sleeve was a relatively new procedure, in that it was only used frequently a few years ago and quickly became the leading bariatric surgery in the United States. But it was based on previous surgeries and similarly effective science. It also was not a technology or a vastly different way of thinking about weight loss. It is not yet known if AspireAssist is safe in controlled, long-term settings, or if it is an effective weight loss solution after the first year. The science behind it is closer to bulimia than bariatric surgery, and while it appears to be safe, it is not yet clear if that safety or efficacy lasts.

3) It is Less Effective – Gastric sleeve and gastric bypass are significantly more effective in the long term, and their safety is well known. While they are permanent, they also do not give you an opportunity to cheat. With AspireAssist, you could theoretically cheat on your diet often and only dump when you want to, and that is going to hurt your weight loss goals and potentially be dangerous in the long term.

It will be interesting to see how the technology compares over time. But at the moment, AspireAssist is too new, too unusual, and not effective enough to be considered recommended. However, in a few years, if there is more research into the device and a standardized way of using it, it will be something that could be considered as an alternative to the Lap-Band. It is just not there yet.

If you have questions about weight loss surgery such as Gastric Sleeve or Gastric Bypass, feel free to contact us through our website or by phone at 1-855-768-7247

Related:
Weight Loss Surgery Options

About the Author:

2 Comments

  1. disapprove April 25, 2018 at 4:42 pm - Reply

    too bad you are not doing aspire assist. i have decided, due to its non invasive nature, ease of placement, fda approval, and success (look it up) i will be getting it done. this article is very negative and i suggest you look to actually doing the operation instead of criticizing it. you are acting like everyone else out there, critical without reason. the lap band is outdated and a poor selection for most with many complications. Try taking that off your list and adding Aspire Assist.

    • Tracy King August 24, 2018 at 5:55 am - Reply

      How are you doing with aspireassist? I’m getting it done in 2 weeks.

Leave A Comment